InstaThink Logo
    InstaThinkLegal
    FeaturesPricingBlogFAQContact
    Get Started
    InstaThink Logo
    InstaThinkLegal

    AI-powered automation for law firms

    Product

    • Features
    • Pricing
    • Blog

    Resources

    • Tools
    • Comparisons
    • How-To Guides

    Company

    • Contact

    Legal

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Service

    Popular States

    CaliforniaNew YorkTexasFloridaIllinoisPennsylvaniaOhioNew JerseyVirginiaMassachusetts

    Practice Areas

    Estate PlanningFamily LawPersonal InjuryCriminal DefenseBusiness LawImmigrationBankruptcyReal Estate

    © 2026 InstaThink. All rights reserved.

    SOC 2 Type II Certified|GDPR Compliant

    Filevine vs MyCase: Enterprise Litigation Platform vs Affordable Practice Management

    Detailed comparison of Filevine and MyCase for law firms. We compare enterprise litigation tools vs affordable small-firm software, pricing, and best use cases.

    Different Tools for Different Stages

    Filevine was founded in 2015 and has grown to serve over 3,000 organizations, with particular strength in the plaintiff and litigation segment. Its phase-based case management system mirrors litigation progression: intake, investigation, demand, negotiation, filing, discovery, trial, and resolution. Each phase has customizable fields, tasks, deadlines, and documents. Filevine also offers Filevine Leads for intake and case acquisition, contract management through its Outlaw acquisition, and advanced reporting for managing partners who need portfolio-level visibility. MyCase, acquired by AffiniPay in 2022, serves over 15,000 law firms primarily in the solo to small segment (1-10 attorneys). Its strengths are affordability (starting at $39/user/month), ease of use (productive within one day), and a polished client portal with secure messaging, e-signatures, and integrated online payments. MyCase serves firms across all practice areas but does not have the litigation-specific depth that Filevine provides. The platforms reflect different operational realities. A 3-attorney personal injury firm processing 10 new cases per month operates differently than a 30-attorney plaintiff firm processing 200+ cases per month. MyCase handles the former efficiently; Filevine is built for the latter.

    Quick Comparison Overview

    FeatureFilevineMyCase
    pricingCustom enterprise pricing, typically $50-$100+/user/mo depending on modulesBasic $39/user/mo, Pro $69/user/mo, Advanced $89/user/mo (billed annually)
    bestFor
    Litigation firms handling high-volume caseloads (50+ active cases per attorney)
    Solo and small firms (1-10 attorneys) wanting affordable, easy-to-use tools
    caseManagement✓✓
    billing✓✓
    documentManagement✓✓
    clientIntakeFilevine Leads: dedicated intake module with lead scoring and source trackingBuilt-in intake forms with e-signatures and payment collection on Pro+ plans
    litigationFeaturesPhase-based management, timeline views, deadline tracking, discovery managementGeneral case management, no litigation-specific phase tracking
    clientPortalBasic client communication features, less polished than MyCasePremium branded portal with messaging, documents, e-signatures, and payments
    customizationDeep: custom fields, phases, sections, and project templates per case typeBasic: custom fields and tags, no phase-based configuration
    reportingEnterprise dashboards with portfolio analytics, team productivity, and pipeline visibilityStandard reports for billing, productivity, and matter status
    mobileAppiOS and Android with full case accessFull iOS and Android with offline access and client messaging

    Litigation Case Management

    Filevine's litigation capabilities are purpose-built and comprehensive. The phase-based system lets firms define exactly how cases progress through their lifecycle. A personal injury case might have phases for intake, medical treatment, demand, negotiation, litigation, and settlement -- each with specific fields (medical providers, treatment costs, demand amounts), tasks (request medical records, send demand letter), and deadlines (statute of limitations, discovery cutoffs). The timeline view provides a visual chronology of every event, document, and communication on a case. Document management handles high-volume discovery with tagging and categorization. Collaboration features enable multiple team members to work on cases simultaneously with real-time updates. Portfolio reporting gives managing partners visibility into case values, pipeline stages, and team performance across hundreds or thousands of cases. MyCase provides general case management that works for any practice area but lacks litigation-specific depth. There is no phase-based progression, no timeline visualization, and no portfolio-level reporting. MyCase handles individual cases well but does not provide the aggregate visibility that high-volume litigation firms need.

    Client Portal and Communication

    MyCase wins decisively on client-facing features. Its client portal is one of the most polished in legal tech: branded interface, secure messaging, document sharing, e-signatures, one-click invoice payment, and built-in text messaging. For consumer-facing practices where client satisfaction drives referrals, MyCase creates a measurably better client experience. Filevine provides basic client communication features but prioritizes internal efficiency over client-facing polish. The platform is designed primarily for the legal team's workflow, not the client's experience. Firms using Filevine often supplement with separate client communication tools or use Filevine's integration capabilities to connect external portals.

    Pricing and Value Analysis

    The price difference is significant. MyCase starts at $39 per user per month (Basic) with its most popular plan at $69 per user per month (Pro). Filevine uses custom enterprise pricing, typically ranging from $50 to $100+ per user per month depending on modules. For a 5-attorney firm, the annual cost ranges from approximately $2,340 (MyCase Basic) to $5,340 (MyCase Advanced) versus $3,000+ to $6,000+ (Filevine). The gap widens when factoring in Filevine's implementation costs and the additional modules (Leads, reporting) that many firms add. The value proposition shifts at scale. A 20-attorney plaintiff firm processing 200+ cases per month extracts far more value from Filevine's litigation tools than it could from MyCase. The portfolio visibility, phase automation, and team collaboration features directly improve case outcomes and firm profitability at that volume.

    The Verdict: Which Is Right for You?

    Choose MyCase if you are a solo or small firm (1-10 attorneys) handling moderate caseloads across diverse practice areas. MyCase's affordability, ease of use, and premium client portal make it the right choice when simplicity and client experience are priorities. Choose Filevine if you are a litigation-focused firm handling high-volume caseloads (50+ active cases per attorney) and need phase-based case tracking, portfolio analytics, and enterprise collaboration. Filevine's litigation depth justifies its cost when your firm's revenue depends on efficient case management at scale. InstaThink adds AI-powered automation to either platform, particularly valuable for intake processing, document generation, and deadline-driven communication workflows.

    Frequently Asked Questions

    When should a growing PI firm switch from MyCase to Filevine?

    Most personal injury firms benefit from switching when they consistently handle 30+ active cases per attorney or have more than 10 attorneys. At that volume, MyCase's lack of phase-based tracking, portfolio reporting, and litigation-specific automation creates operational friction. If your staff spends significant time manually tracking case stages and deadlines across many cases, it is time to evaluate Filevine.

    Is Filevine too complex for a 5-attorney firm?

    Not necessarily. A 5-attorney personal injury firm processing high case volumes would benefit from Filevine's litigation tools. A 5-attorney general practice firm handling family law, estate planning, and criminal defense would find Filevine's complexity unjustified. The decision depends on caseload volume and practice focus, not firm size alone.

    Does Filevine have a client portal like MyCase?

    Filevine provides basic client communication features but does not offer a client portal comparable to MyCase's. MyCase's portal includes a branded interface, secure messaging, document sharing, e-signatures, and one-click payments. Firms choosing Filevine for litigation management often supplement with separate client communication tools.

    Can I migrate from MyCase to Filevine?

    Yes, Filevine provides migration assistance for firms switching from other platforms. Contacts, matters, documents, and billing history can be imported. The primary effort is configuring Filevine's project templates and phases for your practice areas, which requires upfront investment but pays off through ongoing efficiency.

    Automate Your Litigation Workflow

    InstaThink AI-powered workflows handle intake processing, document generation, and deadline management on top of Filevine, MyCase, or any practice management platform.

    Start Free Trial